News

Key Europol documents only made public following access request

None of the decisions adopted by the policing agency's management board since the entry into force of the revamped Europol Regulation last summer were made public, in breach of Europol's own transparency commitments, until Statewatch filed an access to documents request.
None of the decisions adopted by the policing agency's management board since the entry into force of the revamped Europol Regulation last summer were made public, in breach of Europol's own transparency commitments, until Statewatch filed an access to documents request.

In mid-May, Statewatch filed an access to documents request with Europol requesting copies of all decisions adopted by the agency’s management board since 1 June 2022, the same month that legislation granting the agency extensive new powers came into force.

Six weeks later, Europol provided 12 decisions (available below), covering some crucial issues in light of the new powers wielded by the agency – four of the decisions lay down conditions regarding the processing of personal data on potentially vast numbers of people.

This includes personal data received from national and EU institutions and agencies, “private parties”, and “retrieved by Europol from publicly available sources.”

Those four decisions were adopted after a quarrel with the European Data Protection Supervisor, and previous versions of the decisions were excluded from release to Statewatch on the grounds that their publication “could undermine Europol’s the decision-making process by revealing details subject to internal deliberations at Europol”.

Other decisions released deal with the rights and obligations of liaison officers; the designation of the Fundamental Rights Officer; and the secondment of national experts, amongst other things.

No further improvements

In December 2020, in response to a European Ombudsman inquiry that was launched following a complaint filed by Statewatch, Europol claimed (pdf) that its public register of documents “already contains some categories of documents on the core activities of Europol, i.e. legal framework, Executive Director’s decisions and Management Board documents.”

Since then, just one decision of the management board has been added to the agency’s register, and just three decisions of the Executive Director.

Europol’s December 2020 letter said that it aimed to make “further improvement” regarding the addition to its public register of documents released following access requests.

“In the past, due to technical difficulties, some of the documents were not immmediately uploaded on the register of documents. Europol aims to remedy this as soon as possible.”

Whether the technical difficulties have been fixed is unknown – but whether they have been or not, the policing agency is not keeping commitments it made more than two years ago.

Documentation

Decisions of the Management Board of Europol (pdfs):