• Home /
• News /
• 2020 /
• July /
• Counter-terrorism and the Arts: How counter-terrorism policies restrict the right to freedom of expression

Counter-terrorism and the Arts: How counter-terrorism policies restrict the right to freedom of expression

Topic

Country/Region

28 July 2020

A new paper from TNI examines how counter-terrorism law and policy can impinge upon freedom of expression in the arts.

Counter-terrorism and the Arts: How counter-terrorism policies restrict the right to freedom of expression (TNI, link)

"Misuse of anti-terror legislation can threaten freedom of expression both directly, through judicial and procedural application of the law, and via the changes in individuals’ behaviour that the expectation of this can create. Laws criminalizing vaguely defined “extremist activities” or offering too wide a definition of offences “may lead to unnecessary or disproportionate restrictions on the right to freedom of expression”. Three common qualities are necessary in legislation to insure against the misuse of anti-terror legislation to restrict the right to freedom of expression:

• Precision of national law, allowing media and individuals to reasonably foresee the consequences of any expression;
• Restrictions only strictly necessary to protect national security, proportionate to legitimate aims pursued and applied only to content or activities that directly imply the use or threat of violence with the intention to spread fear and terror;
• No undue interference with the role of the media in imparting information of public interest, nor with individuals’ right to seek and receive that information.

This paper will firstly explore the contexts of freedom of expression and counter-terrorism legislation, establishing the importance of both and their development and interaction in national and international law. Then, the application of restrictions to freedom of expression under counter-terror measures will be introduced and the legitimate grounds for doing so, in general and during states of emergency, will be analysed. The case studies of laws passed in Turkey, France, Spain and the United Kingdom are then briefly used to demonstrate a cross section of approaches to the threat of terrorism across the continent, before analysing how these approaches have impacted on freedom of expression, especially in the arts, in these and other European States. Finally, the scoping paper ends with a brief synthesis of trends and impacts across Europe, suggesting further research and recommendations."