News

EU wants more transparency in implementation of new global cybercrime convention

The UN Convention on Cybercrime was adopted on 24 December 2024. Signatory states must introduce a range of criminal offences related to cybercrime, as well as powers for the prevention, detection, investigation and prosecution of those offences. Rules of procedure will set out mechanisms for oversight and monitoring of the Convention, but a draft set of rules has been criticised by civil society groups for their “weak procedures”. An EU paper calls for improvements.
The UN Convention on Cybercrime was adopted on 24 December 2024. Signatory states must introduce a range of criminal offences related to cybercrime, as well as powers for the prevention, detection, investigation and prosecution of those offences. Rules of procedure will set out mechanisms for oversight and monitoring of the Convention, but a draft set of rules has been criticised by civil society groups for their “weak procedures”. An EU paper calls for improvements.

Image: Tianyi Ma, Unsplash


UN Convention on Cybercrime

The UN Convention on Cybercrime requires that all signatory states have legislation to enable the prevention, detection, investigation and prosecution of cybercrime offences.

Those offences includes, for example, illegal access to informations and communications systems; or the illegal interception of electronic data.

The EU is due to sign the treaty, which will apply to areas of law within its competences. Member states, if they are to sign it, will do so separately.

A number of organisations, including Statewatch, previously warned that “the proposed Convention’s use of broad or undefined concepts opens up the risk of widescale human rights violations against civil society.”

Cybercrime laws have often been used by states to target human rights defenders and other critics.

Rules of procedure

Article 57 of the Convention requires that signatory states agree on rules of procedure for a “Conference of the States Parties to the Convention”.

That Conference is supposed to “improve the capacity of and cooperation between States Parties to achieve the objectives set forth in this Convention and to promote and review its implementation.”

Comments from the EU and its member states on the draft rules of procedure (pdf), circulated in the Council of the EU on 3 September, call for the draft rules to be amended.

The introduction to the comments says the rules should “preserve and enhance the level of involvement and participation” of “multistakeholders”.

That includes “relevant non-government organizations, civil society organizations, academic institutions and the private sector.”

In July, three organisations and an individual involved in the negotiations on the Convention published an open letter on the draft rules.

They warned that the draft rules included “weak procedures for monitoring, oversight, accreditation and engagement by non-governmental actors.”

Documentation